Y’all…I did it again. Went to bed w/ a new book at 8:30pm fully anticipating an hour, maybe hour and a half of reading and a reasonable bed time….and ended up reading until 1am. Sigh…I’m so energetically sleepy it’s weird. This must be how toddlers feel when their eyes are half closed but their body is happy dancing at top speed. While delicious, this Green Tea is doing nothing for me.
So, during a book chat last week, a friend linked me to the Amazon Top 20 Chart last week, where I scrolled through the list looking for some new reading material. I was surprised to find 7 Harry Potter books on the list along with the The Handmaid’s Tale. It’s interesting to see so much Harry Potter on the list. I remember seeing the first few books lined up together for the very first time on the library shelf like 15 or 20 years ago and thinking “holy shit, those things are HUGE”. It’s such a strong memory, that to this day I can tell you the exact shelf and location of those books. Weird memories aside, it’s amazing they’ve remained so popular and have really become such a normal part of the cultural sphere. Ready Player One was also an unexpected find, but all of the movie hype has probably got this one ranking high in the charts in anticipation. Like The Martian, Ready Player One has only one real main character in the entire book. I’m interested to see how that translates into a movie.
Having read 9 of the 20 books on this list, I started combing the library for the other 11. Origins by Dan Brown had an 86 person wait list (what-the-what?!?!) but “Before We Were Yours” was available. This book has been on the Amazon Top 20 for 25 weeks now, and after getting so caught up in the web Wingate has weaved, it’s easy to see why.
“Before We Were Yours” is a historical fiction based on the notorious Georgia Tann of the Tennesee Children’s Home Society. From 1920-1950, Tann lied, schemed, plotted, and outright kidnapped the babies and children of America’s poor working class, often taking advantage of young single mothers as she procured children for her black-market baby adoption agency. Most alarmingly, Tann had the support and cooperation of Memphis government officials, who not only knew but enabled her heinous crimes against families and children to continue for decades.
The book is written in a multiple person format, which did take some getting used to at first, particularly as the switch between characters could be jarring at times between chapters. Interestingly enough, the story as told by Avery Stafford is stylistically written very differently than the story as told by Rill Foss and May Crandall . It’s almost like reading two different books. So far, I have preferred the voice and narration of Rill and May. These characters feel very real and very grounded to me, like the author based them on someone she knew well. The story swells and builds around Rill and May, until your heart clenches and you’re holding your breath with each page turn.
Avery, on the other hand, comes across with every stereotypical rich white-girl cliche the author could come up with. She’s from a wealthy Southern family whose roots run deep into the political sphere. She went to Colombia law school where she worked hard to distinguish herself from her own last name and is now a federal prosector. The lawyer thing comes up frequently in Avery’s self monologues, like she’s reminding us over and over that she is smart and capable. She grew up owning/riding horses and spending time with Grandma at the family beach house. Her Daddy is an upstanding honorable man who just so happens to be a US Senator while her mother is the stereotypical overbearing Southern Belle of a Stepford wife whose organizational prowess, social standing and charity work are a force to be reckoned with. While big things loom around her, Avery’s biggest concerns in life are missing her fiancee’s calls and dodging conversations about her wedding plans.
I’m about 75% done with the book and have been reading through Avery’s narration in anticipation of Rill’s and May’s chapters. Looking forward to what the conclusion brings!
One thought on “Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate”