My son, who we’ll call Huck in this blog, LOVES story time and was very disappointed that Mommy couldn’t read him his favorite books while driving him to school in the morning. I attempted a few “from memory” recitations, which never quite hit the mark, before remembering my brother and I having several books on tape that we would sit and listen to over and over and over and over again.
On our next library visit, we found the “reading kits” which contain the book for the child to read and the cd for them to listen. We picked out several and headed home. The ride home (and all subsequent car rides for the next week) was awesome, until it became apparent we were going to listen to the same 5 min story 15 times for each car ride.
Cue the Nancy Drew audio book in the wrong location.
The bright yellow color caught Huck’s eyes and he had to have the yellow audio book. We checked it out and were soon absorbed in a world of 1930’s American mystery. Unlike the children’s books, this book had chapters and it took us about a week to complete. My kid was obsessed, OBSESSED I tell you, with the mystery and we would have to sit in the car listening until we reached the end of each chapter.
At 3, I wasn’t sure he’d be able to follow such a long complex story, but he really surprised me by not only following the story, but coming up with his own ideas, conclusions and plans for catching the bad guy. Over the next few months, we moved through the first five of the original Nancy Drew mysteries before moving on to the Hardy Boys.
Both series are very well written. The characters are well developed and very like-able. The plot is always intriguing and the mystery ending always attempts to be creative. I enjoyed the timelessness of Nancy Drew. Despite the lack of cell phones, which would have ended quite a few of her mysteries before they started, the novels never felt dated and it was easy to relate to Nancy and her friends. The length and complexity of the story was just right to satisfy the literary needs of both Huck and me.
Listening to these books took me straight back to third grade and I enjoyed just as much now as I did then, how Nancy, George, and Bess were presented as strong independent young women who held their own in the mystery world. It was particularly refreshing to “read” about Nancy’s relationships with men. The local police force, for example, respected her ideas, opinions and appreciated her assistance on cases. Her father, a successful lawyer, encouraged Nancy to take chances and follow leads, while also backing her up when she needed it.
The Hardy Boys books are well written as well, but at times felt a bit dated, particularly when they mention money. The Hardy Boys were also still active in their high school social life, leading to a few more characters than Nancy’s trusty sidekicks of George and Bess. The stories were very very good but longer than the Nancy Drew mysteries and at times a little bit more complex. While written about high schoolers, the books seem to be written for a little bit older audience that the Nancy Drew books.
Both my husband and I enjoyed listening to these mysteries with our son, and while I have a notorious affection for F-Bombs and complex tales, I enjoyed the fact that all of the language, scenarios and situations in these books were G rated. These two series are just as good and as satisfying to read as an adult as they were as a child, and I’m rating these as 5 stars and recommending a traditional old ice cream sundae as the choice of drink while reading.